Where Things Come Back

Where Things Come Back (2012), a young adult fantasy novel by John Corey Whaley, won the Michael L. Printz and William C. Morris Awards in 2012. The novel is set in the small town of Lily, Arkansas and concerns a series of strange disappearances and reappearances that happen there.

The novel is told from the point of view of high school senior Cullen Witter, who is desperate to graduate and move away from what he sees as a dead-end town. He goes on a date with an older girl, Alma; when he returns, his older brother Gabriel vanishes. Cullen spends much of the summer searching for his missing brother, but no sign of him ever turns up.

Meanwhile, the novel also introduces a young man named Benton Sage who is working as a missionary in Ethiopia. Difficulties adapting the culture cause him to have a small crisis of faith, but his local contact, Rameel, helps him through it. Rameel is the pastor of a local church that provides food and medical care.



Back in Lily, word has spread that a woodpecker that had been thought extinct has appeared in town. This becomes a major event in town, overshadowing news of Gabriel’s disappearance. Birdwatchers flood the town, and Cullen quickly becomes sick of it. Convinced that Gabriel is dead, he does not want to talk about his disappearance anymore.

Around the same time, Benton returns to the United States, having failed in his missionary work. He attends university, studying English so he can become a novelist. He makes friends with his roommate, Cabot Searcy. However, Benton is still disappointed that his faith in God has been shaken. Over Christmas break, he stays at school, where he commits suicide by jumping from the school bell tower.

Cullen attends work, where he runs into his old friend Ada, who had left town after the deaths of two of her ex-boyfriends. Seeing Ada again causes Cullen to reflect on his situation for the first time. Thinking of how he will never see his older brother again, Cullen begins to cry, and Ada stays nearby to comfort him.



Cullen’s mother contacts a psychic who provides some vague clues about Gabriel’s location. After speaking with her, Cullen’s mother orders Cullen into the car and sets out to find Gabriel. The psychic guides them to an empty field, but Gabriel is not there. Cullen speaks with some of Gabriel’s friends to find out what he might have been thinking or feeling in his final days. Soon after, he receives news from the police that they have had to stop actively searching for Gabriel.

In the meantime, Cabot begins to clean out Benton’s room at university. He finds Benton’s diary, which includes his musings on passages from the Ethiopian Orthodox Bible. Cabot becomes obsessed with the Book of Enoch from the Ethiopian Bible and spends much of his time researching it. While still at school, Cabot meets Alma and, after a whirlwind romance, the two are married.

John Barling, the ornithologist who has come to Lily to prove the existence of the extinct woodpecker, finally takes a photo of the bird, announcing plans to unveil it at an upcoming town festival. Cullen plans to attend the festival, but only so he can see Ada, who has been avoiding him. At the event, he meets John, who tells Cullen that he has always thought it is his destiny to prove that the woodpecker exists.



Alma and Cabot’s marriage begins to disintegrate as Cabot becomes increasingly obsessed with the Book of Enoch and does nothing to help support the household. Alma leaves him, revealing that this portion of the story was a flashback leading up to her date with Cullen at the beginning of the novel.

Cabot follows Alma to Lily and learns Cullen’s address. He goes there to confront Cullen, but runs into Gabriel outside and kidnaps him. In his delusions, he is convinced that Gabriel is the reincarnation of the angel of the same name, so he keeps him captive, grilling him with theological questions. However, after holding Gabriel captive for several months, he becomes disappointed and disillusioned in their conversations.

Back in Lily, John Barling is preparing to leave town. He has received the disappointing news that the bird he thought he had identified as a woodpecker was, in fact, a different species entirely. Cullen is at home thinking about the news when he looks outside and sees Gabriel in the driveway. Gabriel, released by Cabot, has finally made his way back home. Cullen rushes downstairs to meet him, and as the book ends he pokes his brother in the shoulder to make sure that he is real.