The Dante Club

The Dante Club is a mystery novel published by Matthew Pearl in 2003. It is also a work of historical fiction set during the American Civil War, featuring many real historical figures as characters.

In 1865 Boston, Police Chief John Kurtz investigates the brutal and bizarre murder of Supreme Court Justice Artemus Healey. Healey was first hit over the head and knocked unconscious, then left in the garden to be eaten alive by maggots and wasps. Kurtz vows to the judge’s widow that he will solve the crime and bring justice to his murderer.

The scene shifts to a meeting between publisher James Thomas Fields and the treasurer of the Harvard Craper, Dr. Manning. Fields is working with a group of poets and writers including himself, Henry Wadsworth Longfellow, Oliver Wendell Holmes Sr., James Russel Lowell, and George Washington Greene. The men are working to translate the first book of Dante Alighieri’s Divine Comedy, commonly known as the Inferno. They refer to themselves informally as The Dante Club. The work is controversial in 19th century America because of its extreme Catholic point of view, and is officially a prohibited book in heavily Protestant Boston. Harvard as an institution is opposed to the translation, and Dr. Manning tells Fields that he will be removing funds from the project.



Chief Kurtz responds to another bizarre murder; Reverend Talbot, who wrote tracts opposing the translation of Dante’s work on behalf of Harvard, is found buried halfway upside-down over the money that he was paid by Harvard, his feet set on fire.

When the members of The Dante Club hear the details of the murders, they are alarmed because they recognize both incidents as being taken from the Inferno, which is not very well known in America at this time. Judge Healey, who had done nothing to oppose or support the freedom of escaped slaves in the North, was killed similarly to the “Uncommitted” in the poem, people neither good enough for Heaven or bad enough for Hell. Reverend Talbot was killed in the manner of those who accepted bribes. They are worried that these crimes will negatively impact their work, and they are further concerned that since they are among a very small number of people familiar with the Inferno, they will be suspects. As a result, they decide to conduct their own investigation, reasoning that their special knowledge of the poem will give them an advantage. They encounter Nicholas Rey, the first black police officer in Boston, who respects their intelligence even as he is disturbed by their amateur investigation.

There is an incident at Ticknor & Fields, the publishing company co-owned by James Fields. Samuel Ticknor, the son of Field’s deceased partner William D. Ticknor, assaults one of the maids, Cecilia Emory, and shop boy Dan Teal intervenes, saving her.



A third murder occurs. Phineas Jennison, a wealthy member of the Harvard Corporation who had been helping the Dante Club in opposition to his own Protestant community, is found cut open down the middle in the manner of sinners who sowed discord in the poem.

The Dante Club piece together clues and identify Dan Teal as the murderer; George Washington Greene gave a series of lectures on the subject of Dante’s Inferno to soldiers as part of his contribution to the war effort, and Teal, under the name Benjamin Galvin, heard Greene’s sermons as he was struggling with trauma from his experiences as a soldier. Galvin became convinced it was up to him to cleanse the city, using Dante’s work as a guideline for justice and punishment. When Galvin came to Ticknor & Fields and Harvard for employment, he attempted to give his name as Dante Alighieri to honor his bloody inspiration, but was unable to spell it correctly. His scrawl was read as Dan Teal and he adopted the name. The Dante Club attempts to apprehend Teal but he slips away.

One evening Dr. Manning is accosted by one of his students, Pliny Mead, who thinks he can blackmail Manning into receiving a good grade in his class. However, before Mead can even suggest his scheme, Manning hears something heavy falling. Thinking that Mead has broken one of his priceless collectibles, Manning turns and is surprised to find Dan Teal in a military uniform. Teal has hit Mead over the head.



Manning and Teal struggle. Teal has punished anyone he sees as a traitor to the cause of Dante’s Inferno and the attempts to translate his work. The Dante Club arrives in the nick of time as Teal is attempting to drown Manning and Mead in freezing water; they accidentally shoot Mead and rescue Manning from the freezing water, but Teal escapes. When the group later realizes that Holmes is missing, Lowell realizes that at an earlier moment he had referred to Holmes as a traitor to the group in a misunderstanding, and that Teal will likely now go after Holmes. Fields tries to follow Lowell as they race to find Holmes, but he falls behind and is attacked by Teal.

Teal finds Holmes exploring a fugitive slave tunnel under Talbot’s former church. Teal has decided that the Dante Club itself has betrayed his cause, and if Holmes is a traitor to the Club, then he is actually Teal’s ally. He escapes Teal and finds his way to Teal’s secret home, where he discovers Lowell and Fields tied up and gagged. The three men brace for Teal’s arrival, wondering why the promised police protection has not come. Holmes races to Longfellow’s home to save him from Teal. Holmes catches up with Teal as he forcing Longfellow to travel with him and threatens him with a pistol. Teal has placed a revolver in Longfellow’s hand and places his own over it, directing it. Holmes threatens to kill Longfellow, denying Teal the punishment he plans. Teal runs away in a fit of madness and is shot by Manning.