Hoodwink

Hoodwink (1981) is a detective novel by American author Bill Pronzini. It is the seventh novel by Pronzini to feature the protagonist known only as the Nameless Detective. In Hoodwink, the Nameless Detective investigates a locked-room murder that takes place at a convention for writers of pulp novels. In 1982, Hoodwink received the first annual Shamus Award handed out by the Private Eye Writers of America for the Best P.I. Hardcover Novel. As of 2020, Pronzini has published forty-six works of fiction featuring the Nameless Detective as a protagonist.

The Nameless Detective is a private investigator who lives and works in San Francisco. Though his name is never mentioned, some biographical information is revealed about his background throughout the series. Raised by a devout Catholic mother and an abusive alcoholic father, the Nameless Detective serves in the U.S. military during the Vietnam War, working in the intelligence sector. After his discharge from the military, he becomes a police officer and later a private investigator. The Nameless Detective never carries a gun, loves beer, and is a connoisseur of old pulp magazines, printed on cheap wood pulp paper and featuring lurid or exploitative storytelling.

At the beginning of Hoodwink, the Nameless Detective prepares to relocate his office to another neighborhood in San Francisco after the events of the previous book, Labyrinth. Just as he is about to leave, he receives a visit from Russell Dancer. Dancer is an alcoholic pulp writer who before his life began to spiral out of control wrote some of the Nameless Detective's favorite pulp magazines. They also crossed paths before in a previous Nameless case. Dancer says he needs the Nameless Detective's help. After reluctantly agreeing to attend the first annual Western Pulp Convention in San Francisco, Dancer receives a mysterious package containing a short story called "Hoodwink." The story includes a letter that accuses Dancer of plagiarizing the story and demands a blackmail payment to prevent the letter writer from ruining Dancer's reputation. While Dancer now makes a living writing action novels under a pseudonym, he would desperately like to regain his footing and reputation among the pulp writers' community. Therefore, he asks for the Nameless Detective's help in identifying the blackmailer by accompanying him to the Western Pulp Convention. As an ardent pulp fan, the Nameless Detective eagerly agrees to help.



At the convention, the Nameless Detective meets several of his favorite pulp writers. Five of them belong to an informal writers group called the Pulpeteers. Each of the Pulpeteers received a blackmail letter like Dancer's. As Nameless makes the rounds at the convention, subtly inquiring about the blackmail notes, he observes a great deal of rancor and animosity among the pulp writers. The Nameless Detective also meets an attractive young woman named Kerry Wade, the daughter of two prominent pulp writers. The Nameless Detective, however, is uncertain whether Kerry is genuinely interested in him or merely his profession as a private eye. Nevertheless, the Nameless Detective is happy to spend time with a woman who appreciates both pulp magazines and detective work, unlike his ex-girlfriend, Erika. Meanwhile, Dancer is so nervous to be around his old crowd that he consumes a massive amount of alcohol and behaves horribly toward his fellow writers. Practically the entire convention witnesses Dancer get into a massive blowout of a fight with Frank Colodny, the Pulpeteers former editor and the person Dancer comes to believe is responsible for the blackmail notes.

Later in the evening, Colodny is murdered in a locked room. The only other person in the room when Colodny's body is discovered is Dancer, who is caught holding a gun. Drunk beyond comprehension, Dancer has no recollection of shooting Colodny. Despite all the evidence implicating Dancer, however, the Nameless Detective believes he is innocent. As the detective defies the orders of police officers, who understandably believe that Dancer is guilty, he uncovers a complex plot. The blackmail letter is a ploy by one of the other writers who hates Colodny. He sought to make it seem as though Colodny is the one behind the blackmail scheme. This inevitably leads to Dancer having a huge drunken argument with Colodny that everyone in the convention will see. The murderer then takes advantage of Dancer's drunkenness to frame him for Colodny's death.

Though the crime is solved, the book ends on a cliffhanger pertaining to whether the Nameless Detective and Kerry Wade will remain a couple after sleeping with one another.



Hoodwink is an entertaining and twisty detective novel that doubles as a tribute to the old lurid pulp magazines of the 20th century.